First gear is awkward only with the engine running
Easy selection with the engine stopped but difficulty while running suggests checking clutch release before condemning synchronizers. The comparison is useful, but it does not isolate the hydraulic circuit, release mechanism or friction assembly by itself.
Define the selection pattern
Record first gear and reverse behaviour, cold/warm difference and pedal return. Check whether repeated pedal strokes change the symptom and whether the car tends to creep with the clutch fully depressed. Do not force gears to obtain a result.
Compare release travel and linkage
A workshop should inspect the manual gearbox's hydraulic supply, pedal and release arrangement and evaluate clutch drag using the correct procedure. Air or internal leakage can reduce release without a visible puddle. Mechanical distortion or release-bearing issues can produce a similar running-only pattern.
If selection is also poor with the engine off, investigate cable/linkage adjustment or gearbox mechanisms separately. Lubricant requirements must match the gearbox, but changing fluid does not repair inadequate clutch release. One observation should select a test, not a replacement disc automatically.
Verify after the demonstrated correction
Repair the proven hydraulic, release, clutch or linkage defect. Bleeding is appropriate when required, but cannot cure damaged mechanics. Check the original condition after warm operation, not only a cold selection with the engine stopped.
Outcome & verification
Confirm smooth running-engine selection, full pedal return and no unintended creep or leakage, using controlled professional checks.
Community discussion
Owner experiences, questions and other possible solutions.
No owner experiences yet. Share what was checked and what happened.
Sign in to share your experienceHelpful votes reflect community experience. Repair outcomes are self-reported.