AI4Car

Oil use persists after PCV work: verify regulation, then investigate other paths

A4 B8Engine & lubrication
The problem

A ventilation repair can correct abnormal crankcase regulation without resolving every source of oil consumption. Continued loss after PCV work does not automatically prove either that the repair failed or that the engine needs a rebuild. The next decision needs measured evidence.

Compare the loss before and after

Use the same oil specification, checking method and recorded distance where practical. Confirm the replacement matches the engine and any applicable revision requirements. A change in the warning interval alone is a poor comparison if starting levels or driving conditions differ.

Record whether idle, whistle or mixture faults improved. That may show the ventilation repair addressed one real defect even if a second problem remains.

Check the repaired system and remaining routes

A workshop should verify crankcase pressure to the correct engine reference rather than judge the new part by oil-cap feel. Inspect connected hoses and sealing boundaries. If regulation remains abnormal, establish why before moving to another diagnosis.

With regulation correct, investigate external leaks, turbo-related oil movement and internal engine condition as evidence supports. Intake oil quantity, spark-plug condition and smoke pattern can guide the next test, but none should be treated as a standalone verdict. Normal compression does not exclude every oil-control problem.

Set a reasoned threshold for major work

Ask for a controlled consumption assessment and the findings that isolate the likely path. Do not replace another PCV unit simply because it was the previous repair, or authorise pistons because the first repair was inexpensive and did not solve everything. Different causes can coexist.

Outcome & verification

Document verified ventilation operation and the measured remaining oil use. After further repair, repeat the same assessment rather than relying on the absence of a low-level message for a few journeys.

Keep oil within the specified range. Stop for pressure warnings, severe smoke or abnormal mechanical noise and avoid unapproved additives as a substitute for diagnosis.
Discuss this problem ↓

Community discussion

Owner experiences, questions and other possible solutions.

No owner experiences yet. Share what was checked and what happened.

Sign in to share your experience

Helpful votes reflect community experience. Repair outcomes are self-reported.